betterjobs

Free form template · Word

Manager Performance Review

A manager performance review form is used by a senior leader to appraise a people manager or team lead. Besides individual results it rates how well the manager delivers through the team: team targets, hiring, retention, coaching, fair appraisals and compliance with people policies.

  • Editable Word (.docx)
  • Made for India
  • 26 fill-in fields highlighted
  • Free, no sign-up

Preview of the form

[Highlighted] = fill in
[Company Logo][Company Name]

MANAGER PERFORMANCE REVIEW FORM

Company:
[Company Name]
Review Period:
[DD/MM/YYYY] to [DD/MM/YYYY]
Team Size:
[Number] direct / [Number] total
Employee Name[Employee Name]
Employee ID[Employee ID]
Designation[Designation]
Department[Department]
Reporting Manager[Reporting Manager]
Date of Joining[Date of Joining]
Work Location[Work Location]

Rating Scale

RatingLabelMeaning
5OutstandingConsistently exceeds all expectations; a role model for others
4Exceeds ExpectationsFrequently goes beyond targets and standards
3Meets ExpectationsFully delivers what the role requires
2Needs ImprovementMeets some expectations; clear gaps to close
1UnsatisfactoryDoes not meet the basic requirements of the role

Section A: Team Metrics

MetricTargetActualComments
Team target achievement (%)[Target][Actual][Comments]
Voluntary attrition (%)[Target][Actual][Comments]
Average time to fill open roles (days)[Target][Actual][Comments]
Appraisals and reviews completed on time (%)[Target][Actual][Comments]

Section B: Business Results

ObjectiveWeightage (%)AchievementRating (1–5)
[Objective 1][%][Achievement][Rating]
[Objective 2][%][Achievement][Rating]
[Objective 3][%][Achievement][Rating]

Section C: People Leadership

CompetencyRating (1–5)Example
Sets clear goals and expectations[Rating][Example]
Coaches and develops team members[Rating][Example]
Gives timely, fair feedback and ratings[Rating][Example]
Hires well and onboards effectively[Rating][Example]
Builds a respectful, safe workplace (POSH, grievance handling)[Rating][Example]
Communicates change and decisions[Rating][Example]

Section D: Upward Feedback Summary

Themes the team appreciates[Themes]
Themes the team wants improved[Themes]

Section E: Overall Rating and Development

Overall rating (1–5)[Rating]
Leadership behaviour to build next[Behaviour]
Development support (programme, coach, mentor)[Support]

Manager comments:
[Employee Comments]

Manager Reviewed
[Employee Name]
Date: [Date]
Reviewing Leader
[Reporting Manager]
Date: [Date]
HR Business Partner
[HR Name]
Date: [Date]

What this template includes

  • Team metrics such as target achievement, attrition and open positions
  • People leadership competencies rated on a five-point scale
  • Business results section separate from people results
  • Upward feedback summary from team members
  • Development plan for leadership skills
  • Reviewer and HR sign-off

When to use it

  • Annual or half-yearly appraisal of team leads, managers and HODs
  • Reviewing a newly promoted first-time manager
  • Assessing managers whose teams show high attrition or low engagement
  • Linking manager bonus to team outcomes

How to customise this template

  1. 1Fill team metrics from HRMS reports (headcount, exits, time to fill)
  2. 2Weight people and business results to suit the role (e.g. 50:50)
  3. 3Attach an anonymous upward feedback summary if collected
  4. 4Add compliance items relevant to your sector, such as shift rosters or safety audits

HR tips

  • Separate the manager’s own output from the team’s output
  • Look at regretted attrition, not only total attrition
  • Do not share individual upward feedback comments that could identify team members
  • Agree one leadership behaviour to build in the next cycle

For HR & hiring managers

Hire top talent from BetterJobs

Experienced and fresher candidates across India — blue, grey and white collar. Post a job in 5 minutes and start receiving applications.

  • Post in 5 minutesDescribe the role in one line — we write the job description.
  • Verified applicantsEvery applicant has a verified mobile number.
  • Resume databaseSearch experienced candidates by skill, city and experience.

Frequently asked questions

How is a manager’s performance evaluated?+

On business results delivered by the team plus people leadership: hiring, coaching, retention, fair reviews, communication and policy compliance.

Should team feedback be part of a manager review?+

Yes. Anonymous upward feedback gives a useful view of leadership behaviour, provided it is summarised to protect confidentiality.

Who reviews a manager?+

Usually the manager’s own reporting manager or business head, with HR facilitating and calibrating ratings.