betterjobs

Free form template · Word

Peer Review Form

A peer review form collects structured feedback from colleagues who work closely with an employee. Peers rate collaboration, reliability, knowledge sharing and quality of joint work, and give specific examples, adding a view the reporting manager may not see day to day.

  • Editable Word (.docx)
  • Made for India
  • 13 fill-in fields highlighted
  • Free, no sign-up

Preview of the form

[Highlighted] = fill in
[Company Logo][Company Name]

PEER REVIEW FORM

Company:
[Company Name]
Review Cycle:
[YYYY–YY]
Return to HR by:
[DD/MM/YYYY]

Employee Being Reviewed

Employee Name[Employee Name]
Designation[Designation]
Department[Department]

About Your Working Relationship

How do you work with this colleague? (same team / cross-team project / internal customer)[Answer]
For how long have you worked together? [Months]

Rating Scale

RatingLabelMeaning
5OutstandingConsistently exceeds all expectations; a role model for others
4Exceeds ExpectationsFrequently goes beyond targets and standards
3Meets ExpectationsFully delivers what the role requires
2Needs ImprovementMeets some expectations; clear gaps to close
1UnsatisfactoryDoes not meet the basic requirements of the role

Peer Ratings

BehaviourRating (1–5)Example (required for ratings of 1, 2 or 5)
Delivers on commitments made to the team[Rating][Example]
Shares knowledge and helps others[Rating][Example]
Communicates clearly and on time[Rating][Example]
Handles disagreements constructively[Rating][Example]
Quality of work I receive from them[Rating][Example]
Treats colleagues with respect[Rating][Example]

Open Feedback

This colleague’s greatest strength[Comment]
One suggestion that would make them even more effective[Comment]

Confidentiality

Your feedback will be combined with other reviewers’ responses and shared as a summary. Please keep comments factual and professional, and do not discuss your review with the colleague concerned.

Reviewer (kept confidential by HR)
[Reviewer Name]
Date: [Date]

What this template includes

  • Relationship and duration of working together for context
  • Five-point rating scale legend
  • Ratings on collaboration and teamwork behaviours
  • Mandatory example for high and low ratings
  • Strengths and one suggestion for growth
  • Confidentiality statement

When to use it

  • Input to an annual appraisal or promotion decision
  • Project-based teams where peers see more of the work than the manager
  • Agile and cross-functional teams after a sprint or release
  • Part of a 360-degree feedback exercise

How to customise this template

  1. 1Ask the employee and manager to nominate three to five peers
  2. 2Remove behaviours that peers cannot observe
  3. 3Decide whether the reviewer’s name will be shared with the employee
  4. 4Combine forms into one summary before sharing

HR tips

  • Choose peers who have worked with the person for at least three months
  • Ask for observable behaviour, not opinions about personality
  • Brief reviewers to avoid comments on caste, religion, gender or personal life
  • Never use peer feedback alone for a pay or disciplinary decision

For HR & hiring managers

Hire top talent from BetterJobs

Experienced and fresher candidates across India — blue, grey and white collar. Post a job in 5 minutes and start receiving applications.

  • Post in 5 minutesDescribe the role in one line — we write the job description.
  • Verified applicantsEvery applicant has a verified mobile number.
  • Resume databaseSearch experienced candidates by skill, city and experience.

Frequently asked questions

What is a peer review in performance appraisal?+

It is feedback given by colleagues at a similar level about how an employee collaborates and contributes, used alongside the manager’s assessment.

How many peers should review an employee?+

Three to five peers who work closely with the employee usually give a balanced view.

Should peer reviews be anonymous?+

Many companies keep them confidential and share only a summary, which encourages candid but respectful feedback.